Posts in the 'Media' Category

Action needed to combat campaign delegitimizing Israel

By Sam Sokolove on Tuesday, March 2nd, 2010 at 2:53 pm
Categories: Advocacy, Media

By Martin J. Raffel

The organized American Jewish community and our non-Jewish allies, with broad representation from across political and religious lines, are poised to launch a major initiative to counter the campaign to delegitimize Israel.

The sky is not falling. President Obama and the U.S. Congress remain firmly committed to Israel’s fundamental security, and opinion polls consistently reflect broad American public support for the Jewish state. But there are clouds gathering on the horizon that must not be ignored.

The delegitimization campaign — and make no mistake, it is a global campaign — has its roots in the international NGO gathering that took place alongside the 2001 U.N. conference on racism in Durban, South Africa. With the second intifada (more aptly described as “Arafat’s terror war”) raging, these anti-Israel NGOs decided to open up a second front to paint Israel as a pariah/apartheid state deserving of political and economic isolation.

Through the years, the principal weapons used by these groups are the boycott of Israeli products, people and events; divestment from Israeli companies and institutions, including Israel Bonds, as well as from certain foreign companies doing business in Israel; and sanctions. This explains why the campaign to delegitimize Israel often is referred to, inadequately and misleadingly, simply as the BDS movement.

There is no central address orchestrating all of the delegitimization activity. Rather we see a loose network of NGOs across the globe, sometimes coalescing around particular spheres, such as the U.S. Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel.

Mainline Protestant churches, universities, municipalities and corporations have processed divestment initiatives, which in virtually every case have failed to gain traction. The divestment language in a 2004 resolution adopted by the Presbyterian Church USA has since been rescinded, but the issue continues to capture the imagination of Israel’s detractors in that church and others.

Israeli cultural events have been subject to boycott attempts, such as the performances of the Israeli ballet now touring the United States and the Toronto Film Festival last fall, which was dedicated to Tel Aviv’s 100th anniversary.

Campuses have been particular targets, with Israel Apartheid Week taking place the first two weeks in March. The delegitimizers prey on those who lack basic knowledge about the complex nature of Middle East politics — people who can easily fall victim to their simplistic and often inaccurate narratives.

In parallel to the NGOs, governments, especially operating through deeply biased U.N. bodies such as the Geneva-based Human Rights Council, continue to promulgate material that fairly can be described as delegitimizing long after revocation of the 1975 resolution equating Zionism with racism.

The Goldstone report, which grossly distorts the reality of Israel’s efforts to combat an amoral adversary in Gaza that uses civilians as human shields — is the latest in a long line of hostile actions emanating from the council.

Accusations of war crimes and crimes against humanity eagerly get picked up by the delegitimization organizations and coalitions as valuable weapons in their arsenals.

Indeed, public international law has increasingly been utilized as a rationale for imposing political and economic sanctions against Israel.

Re’ut, an Israel-based think tank, recently completed an analysis of the issue and concluded that “while Israel’s delegitimizers come from relatively marginal forces in Europe, their effectiveness stems from their ability to engage and mobilize others. This is accomplished by branding Israel as a pariah and ‘apartheid’ state, identifying ‘outstanding issues’ — such as the ‘Gaza blockade,’ ’settlements,’ ‘the separation wall,’ ‘occupation,’ ‘disproportionate use of force,’ or ‘human rights violations’ — and rallying their coalition around it; making pro-Palestinian activity trendy; promoting boycotts, divestments and sanctions; and, most importantly, blurring the line separating them from those that criticize Israeli policy yet do not delegitimize it.”

Re’ut points out that “the delegitimizers work ‘from the periphery to the center’ and ‘bottom-up, thriving in social networks and on the Internet. Hence, while in formal policy spheres Israel’s diplomatic position remains relatively strong and solid, its standing among the general public and intellectual elites is being eroded.”

It is true that Israel’s “diplomatic position” for the time being remains strong both with the U.S. government and the American people. However, as the JCPA resolution on countering the delegitimization campaign adopted at our recent annual conference maintains, “unless effectively countered, over time it may have the corrosive effect of changing the culture of political discussion and making it harder for people of goodwill to publicly support Israel. If support for Israel begins to be seen as de facto racism, this could provide fertile ground for the growth of anti-Semitism.”

The delegitimization campaign, unfortunately, has made significant inroads in other parts of the world. Friends of Israel in this country cannot afford to be complacent. The community relations field — with motivated activists in our own community joined by non-Jewish allies who come to this cause based on relationships forged around a range of joint efforts in the social justice and human rights arenas — is well positioned to develop a strategic and comprehensive response to this challenge.

We must act now to prevent the clouds from becoming a full-fledged storm.


Talking Points on Settlements

By Sam Sokolove on Wednesday, June 3rd, 2009 at 11:10 am
Categories: Media, News

Israel strongly desires peace with the Palestinians and the entire Arab world.

As Prime Minister Netanyahu said in Washington after his meeting with President Obama on May 18, “I want to make it clear that we don’t want to govern the Palestinians. We want to live in peace with them.” He also expressed readiness to engage immediately and unconditionally in intensive bilateral negotiations with the Palestinian leadership to resolve all outstanding issues.

Israel and the Palestinian leadership agreed to the terms of the Quartet’s performance-based Roadmap for Peace and both sides should be expected to fulfill their obligations under it.

The question of Jewish settlement in the West Bank and Gaza Strip has long been a source of disagreement between Israeli governments and American administrations. We urge both the Obama administration and Netanyahu government not to allow any current differences over settlements to obscure the fundamental agreement they share on the broad geo-strategic challenges in the Middle East, including the need to reach a negotiated settlement between Israel and the Palestinians.

We believe that it would be a fundamental mistake for the United States to consider using any disagreement over settlements as a rationale for withholding economic, diplomatic or military support necessary for Israel’s security and survival.


Sam N. Lehman-Wilzig’s TIPS FOR ISRAEL ADVOCATES

By Sam Sokolove on Wednesday, April 1st, 2009 at 7:53 am
Categories: General Commentary, Israel, Media

Prof. Sam Lehman-Wilzig, the Schusterman Visiting Israeli Scholar, Brown University, visited Albuquerque recently to address the topic of “Can Israel Do a Better PR Job?”

 His facinating discussion offered background on the relationship of the Israeli government to the Israeli media and how this is a major reason for the Israeli governments’ historical complacency and lack of focus on “hasbarah” (professional PR) vis-a-vis explaining its policies to the rest of the world. 

The following are suggestions Professor Lehman-Wilzig offered to Israel advocates as to how they can help as part of Israel’s larger general PR campaign.

 Truth: most Americans don’t care about Foreign Policy unless it really impacts their lives: (1974 oil embargo — gas prices go up!).

Rather, most Americans see the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as a regional problem, not a local one. “Public opinion is overrated,” says Dr. Lehman-Wilzig. “What is really important (is reaching) the opinion leaders – people who set policy.”  

Main Advocacy Efforts Should Be Focused on:

  • Political leadership itself: AIPAC, for example, goes to officials at the most grassroots level; they go to up- and-comers, make a long-term investment in education and mentorship, and this ultimately influences policy;
  • Social Opinion Makers: Clergy, media personalities, academics.”You never know when a singer will say something positive about Israel; this can be hugely beneficial;”
  • Journalists (print, electronic, radio).  

 Main Advocacy Messages

  • Make sure the basic facts get out — e.g., Arafat’s rejection of 96% of the West Bank; Hamas’ launch of 6,000 missiles, etc. — you’ll be amazed by how little information is actually out there;
  • Try to Persuade: this includes Israel’s right to exist, right to defend herself and the truth that Israel is honestly seeking peace. This isn’t accomplished by browbeating, which may have only a short-term success; persuasion is long-term, civil, and best handled face-to-face;
  • Normalize and Civilize Israel: It’s a place where people can actually live a normal life; it’s technologically advanced nation, a leader in computer tech, etc.  When people read about Israel, 90% of the time it’s in the context of war, crisis – as advocates, we should “lower the disaster quotient” and show the normalcy!  (BTW: this talk happened the same day the polling firm Dahaf, on behalf of the Jerusalem Institute of Market Studies, released a survey revealing that a majority of Israelis are happy — 30 percent, in fact, in fact very happy.

“American Jews don’t have to tote the Israeli government line… it’s our job to learn more about what makes Israel tick,” he says. In other words, the more we see and portray an “Israel beyond the conflict,” the more effective our advocacy work will be.

 


Join Us for Official Website Launch

By Sam Sokolove on Tuesday, March 24th, 2009 at 10:31 am
Categories: Israel, Media, News

Launch of the New Mexico Israel Advocacy Corps Website

Tuesday, March 31, 6:00 p.m. at the JCC in Albuquerque

Under the auspices of the JFNM, http://nmisrael.org/ has been established to offer resources to local Israel Advocates, including talking points, background materials and information on the Sister Cities Project.

Web designer Andrew Jaffee, a member of the JFNMs Israel Advocacy Task Force, has been enlisted to build the website. Israel Task Force members are asked to attend this gathering for a site tour and to make assignments for follow-up and content.


Response to Jerry Ortiz Y Pino (ALIBI, February 5-11)

By Sam Sokolove on Friday, March 6th, 2009 at 11:41 am
Categories: Israel, Media

 

February 8, 2009

 

Re: “Letter to the Editor” (Jerry Ortiz Y Pino, February 5-11)

 

In defending the remarks of Council President Benton regarding Israel’s Operation Cast Lead – remarks which Councilman Benton has since apologized for — Mr. Ortiz y Pino unfortunately reiterates a host of disproven accusations against the Jewish State.

 

First, the genocide charge against Israel is particularly odious: if Israel truly has such designs, how has the population of the West Bank and Gaza managed to grow from 950,000 in 1967 to approximately 2.6 million today? Contra Mr. Ortiz y Pino it is totally appropriate to make a big deal out of a false accusation of Genocide.  That term — coined by a Jewish survivor of Nazism — has no equivalence to Israel’s policies, which two years ago saw Israel unconditionally withdraw from Gaza to allow the Palestinian population self-determination.

 

Sadly, instead of the lives of Gazans improving, the region became a terror base for Hamas. Behind the tragedy of dead children are Hamas terrorists who choose to launch mortars from schoolyards, and hide rockets in apartment buildings, callously imperiling their own people.

 

As for Mr. Ortiz y Pino’s Apartheid charge, it’s worth noting that despite the mendacious title of his 2006 book, former President Carter actually never claimed that Israel engages in the racist policies of pre-1994 South Africa, which legislated a vision of racial superiority completely absent from Israeli governmental rule. “Apartheid” and “Genocide” are no less offensive than “Ethnic Cleansing” when misapplied to the most religiously and ethnically diverse nation in the Middle East.

 

While reciting a litany of pejoratives to condemn Israel, Mr. Ortiz y Pino manages to overlook the basic motivation behind Israel’s recent military actions: to halt the thousands of rockets that have been fired from Gaza into Israel, with more than 500,000 Israelis in the direct range of these weapons. Thus, Mr. Ortiz y Pino ignores the most truthful phrase to convey Israeli policy: a country’s simple right to self-defense.

 

Sincerely,

 

Robert Efroymson                                                              

President, Jewish Federation of New Mexico


Combating Lies About Israel: The Truth Is Out There

By Andrew Jaffee on Monday, February 23rd, 2009 at 11:08 am
Categories: Israel, Media

As usual, during a Palestinian-Israeli conflict, the international press readily eats up all sorts of exaggerated claims made by the Arab side. This time — during Israel’s attempt to stop constant, terrorist rocket fire from Gaza — the IDF (Israeli Defense Forces) was accused of shelling a UN school. Remember that during the “second intifada” in 2002, Yasir Arafat accused Israel of “massacring” thousands of Palestinians in the battle of Jenin. In fact, “The death toll was 56 Palestinians, the majority of them combatants, and 23 Israeli soldiers.” No massacre. The problem is that once the media reports on accusations leveled against Israel, it rarely steps back to correct the lies. Maybe a footnote is added to one or two stories, but the public relations damage to Israel’s image has already been done. This time, will the media report on the true facts revealed about the IDF’s “school shelling,” or Hamas’ use of its own people as human shields, or Hamas’ stealing of UN emergency supplies destined for those Palestinians who really need it? It can seem hopeless, but the truth is out there.

(continue reading…)


All content Copyright © 2009 by The Jewish Federation of New Mexico
Designed, developed, and maintained by netwmd.com, LLC